Love and Longing in Bombay

This past week I made my maiden voyage to the city of Bombay/ Mumbai – a little late in my career as an Indian citizen, I’m aware, but as the adage reassures me, more timely than never. It’s true I had the benefit of post-monsoon, pre-October-heat weather and a convenient ignorance of what goes on on its darker streets, but what I saw of the city absolutely charmed me. With restaurants actually patronised by their owners (a seal of approval all franchisees so tellingly lack), entire streets dedicated solely to fabrics or hardware or… light fixtures (!), and auto drivers who voluntarily give you one-rupees change, I felt like I was in some sort of urban heaven, replete with all of the character my own city of Bangalore seems so glad to shake off.

I got back home and, flush with the excitement of a new city, got to work finding a book that would keep it fresh in my mind. I bypassed Shantaram, which I decided would be too obvious a choice, and singled in instead on Vikram Chandra’s Love and Longing in Bombay – a book incidentally recommended by what seemed like every book reviewer/ reviewing body on the planet. It won the Commonwealth Writers Prize for Best Book in the Eurasia Region and is, I’m told by James Wood of the Guardian, ‘full and free and utterly alive, crossing and recrossing contemporary Bombay… These stories offer a world.’

The book is a collection of five short stories related by a retired civil servant, Subramanium, about five unrelated Bombay personalities – a military man confronting a ghost from his past, a social climber on aspirational Malabar Hill, a police inspector simultaneously investigating a murder and the demise of his marriage, a man on a train with some homosexual + underworld linkages… okay, I’m just going to admit I didn’t finish the book. The writing isn’t bad. No, it’s lyrical and poetic and all it’s supposed to be. This got me through the first three stories, but I finally accepted that nothing was gripping me as I embarked upon the fourth. I gave up because, to me, that’s all they were – stories. They were interesting enough tales, I suppose, but I wanted something a little more insightful, something more than a booth bangla/ murder-mystery story, and I didn’t get it. More specifically, I wanted some sense of place, especially from a title that suggests the author was particularly concerned with cultivating this same sense. Saying something happened on Carter Road or Marine Drive or in Crawford Market isn’t enough to recreate that ‘world’ I was promised.

This is beginning to verge on scathing and I don’t mean for it to. I’d be more than happy if someone could enlighten me as to what I missing. I’m not saying it’s a bad book, just that packaging it as love and longing in Bombay feels a little gimmicky, and it left me feeling cheated by all those undelivered promises. No, I’m not saying it’s a bad book – just that I’ll probably read Shantaram instead.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

20 Responses to Love and Longing in Bombay

  1. Great post. Anticipating the next one.

  2. SSquo says:

    I really liked Love and longing in Bombay, and I think the level of liking the book may have to do with where you are from. The booth-bangla etc. description that you were looking for is probably not what Vikram was going for, and I say this coz as someone who has lived in Bombay I related to it, and especially so to the routines of life, the little things we have live through, the lives of a Dolly and a Shaila etc.

    Haven’t read Shantaram, so can’t compare.

  3. I agree with your Blog and I will be back to check it more in the future so please keep up your work. I love your content & the way that you write. It looks like you’ve been doing this for a while now, how long have you been blogging for?

  4. Kicker says:

    Hola, – da mejor. Guardar va!


  5. bet365 says:

    how are you!This was a really impressive theme!
    I come from roma, I was luck to search your website in bing
    Also I obtain much in your theme really thank your very much i will come daily

  6. bet365 says:

    how are you!This was a really fabulous subject!
    I come from itlay, I was fortunate to discover your Topics in bing
    Also I obtain a lot in your Topics really thanks very much i will come again

  7. bet365 says:

    hello I was fortunate to seek your topic in baidu
    your Topics is splendid
    I learn a lot in your theme really thanks very much
    btw the theme of you site is really impressive
    where can find it

  8. Hallo
    Toller Blog, aber leider sehe ich nur die hälfte.Ist Euch das bekannt?
    Liegt das an meinem Safari?

    Gruß aus Essen

  9. abnehmen says:

    What is captcha code?, pls present me captcha code codes or plugin, Thanks ahead of time.

  10. daidaihua says:

    Super-Duper site! I’m loving it!! Will come back again again – taking you feeds also, Thanks.

  11. bet365 says:

    Good day!This was a really marvelous theme!
    I come from milan, I was luck to find your blog in digg
    Also I get much in your theme really thanks very much i will come daily

  12. Bertrand Russell~ Man wants for his happiness not only the satisfaction of this or that but hope and enterprise and alter.

  13. Hey, I tried to email you pertaining to this submit but aren?t in a position to reach you. Please e-mail me when get a moment. Thanks.

  14. I have interpret a insufficient of the articles on your website now, and I definitely like your tastefulness of blogging. I added it to my favorites entanglement page roster and last will and testament be checking assist soon. Cheer repress out my put as well and let me be acquainted with what you think. Thanks.

  15. great information you write it very clean. I’m very lucky to get

    this details from you.

  16. Video says:

    Спасибо понравилось ! Thanks !

  17. Ilias says:

    Hola, ЎGracias por el artнculo. Cada vez que quieres leer.


  18. I know this is really boring and you are skipping to the next comment, but I just wanted to throw you a big thanks – you cleared up some things for me!

  19. that is Also nice, when it comes in india hope it can make a Rocking place for youngster.. hope that
    come accurate.

  20. Interesting…and I agree with all of it. Keep up the excellent work…I will undoubtedly be back soon

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *